top of page

The arrival (and management) of self-critique in teams that discover Psychological Safety.

The Paradox of Opening Up: Navigating the Complexities of Psychological Safety in Teams




In the evolving landscape of team dynamics, the concept of psychological safety has emerged as a cornerstone for fostering innovation, creativity, and resilience.


Psychological safety, as defined by Amy Edmondson, a renowned professor at Harvard Business School, refers to a team climate characterised by interpersonal trust and mutual respect, where team members feel safe to take risks and be vulnerable in front of each other.


However, this journey towards psychological safety is not without its complexities and paradoxes. One of the most intriguing challenges that teams encounter as they embrace this culture is the increase in self-critical behaviour and negative self-perception.


As teams become more comfortable in expressing their thoughts and feelings, underlying issues that were previously hidden beneath a veil of formal professionalism begin to surface. This can lead to an initial phase where teams may appear more self-critical and even negative about their performance and dynamics. This can create fear in the leader, or the team itself, that the team is breaking apart as it starts to create safety.

Let's explore the benefits of this outcome and how best to lead a team through these changes, towards empathy and effective teaming.


Understanding the Dynamics of Open Communication

The shift towards open communication in psychologically safe teams often unveils a range of issues – from minor misunderstandings to deep-seated conflicts. This newfound openness is a double-edged sword; while it fosters honesty and authenticity, it also brings to light the flaws and weaknesses that team members might have been unaware of, chosen to ignore or been afraid to air.


For managers and leaders, this phase can be particularly disconcerting. The sudden influx of candid feedback, critical self-appraisal, and interpersonal issues can create an impression that the team is breaking apart. However, it is crucial to understand that this phase is a normal and necessary part of the team’s evolution towards greater cohesion and effectiveness.





Navigating the Challenges: A Guide for Managers and Leaders

  1. Reframe the Narrative: As a leader, it's important to reframe this phase not as a breakdown but as an opportunity for growth and development. Recognise that the surfacing of issues is a sign of trust and comfort among team members.

  2. Maintain a Balanced Perspective: Encourage your team to maintain a balance between self-critique and recognition of strengths. It’s vital to acknowledge successes and positive aspects alongside areas that need improvement.

  3. Foster Constructive Feedback: Guide your team in providing feedback that is constructive and aimed at growth. Teach them to focus on behaviours and processes, rather than personal attributes.

  4. Embrace Vulnerability: Lead by example by showing vulnerability. This helps in normalising the expression of doubts and uncertainties, making it a part of the team’s growth process.

  5. Provide Support and Resources: Offer resources such as workshops, coaching sessions, or team-building activities that focus on communication, conflict resolution, and emotional intelligence. This support can help teams navigate through the complexities of their interactions.

  6. Encourage Reflection and Dialogue: Create spaces for regular reflection and open dialogue. Encourage team members to share their feelings, fears, and aspirations. This practice helps in building empathy and understanding within the team.

  7. Monitor and Adjust: Continuously monitor the team dynamics and be ready to adjust your approach. Be open to feedback about your leadership style and be willing to make changes to support your team better.






The Road to Resilience and Enhanced Performance

As teams navigate through this challenging phase of increased self-critique and openness, they gradually learn to balance honesty with empathy and constructive feedback with appreciation of each other’s strengths. This journey, though fraught with initial hurdles, leads to a more resilient and high-performing team. The environment of psychological safety, once fully embraced and integrated, becomes the foundation for a team that is not only effective in its tasks but also robust in its interpersonal dynamics.


The Role of Psychological Safety in Long-Term Team Development

In conclusion, the path to psychological safety is a transformative process for teams. It invites a deeper understanding of each other and fosters an environment where challenges can be addressed constructively. For managers and leaders, recognising the positive long-term implications of this phase is crucial. By guiding their teams through this period with empathy, support, and a clear vision, they can help unlock the team's full potential, leading to sustainable growth and success.


In essence, the journey towards psychological safety is an invitation to repair, develop, and thrive. It is a testament to the team's strength, not a sign of its weakness. As teams continue to embrace this culture, they set themselves on a trajectory towards greater collaboration, innovation, and resilience – key ingredients for success in today’s complex and ever-changing organizational landscapes.

0 views
bottom of page